Tools

County Officials React to Medical Examiner Controversy

By KGNS News

We first brought you the news that Webb County medical examiner Corinne Stern had not taken her state oath of office as some say is required by the State constitution.
It could affect hundreds, perhaps even thousands of cases overseen by Stern. Ultimately County officials would have to make sure she takes the oath. Something some say should have been done from day one on the job.
"Until such time as she has taken the oath with the appointment as medical examiner, then everything she did prior to that is void."
That was County Attorney Anna Laura Cavazos yesterday after hearing from a State constitutional expert and doing some research of her own into whether or not Webb County medical examiner Corrine Stern needed to take an oath of office in order to carry out her duties as a forensic expert.
"It doesn't change the result. It only changes her authority to give the conclusions that she did as result as an examination."
"It is my understanding that she took the oath today."
He also adds that different counties require the oath to be taken and that not all do.
"But to be on the safe side, she did take an oath today so that cures whatever issues are out there."
However, we found under the Texas constitution that it states something different. In article sixteen, it states elected and appointed officers are required to sign an "anti-bribery statement" before taking the constitutional oath or affirmation of office. The argument being made from the County is "These are not appointed positions. These are employees of the County. We'll make sure she has the right credentials."
Under State law all medica examiners are appointed positions by commissioner courts. Canales says he actually spoke to the medical examiner Corinne Stern yesterday about this issue and she didn't know anything having to sign an oath.
"She just told me that she was never told that she had to sign an oath." "Yesterday we talked to the county attorney who said she should have taken her oath when she was hired and now you're saying she doesn't need it." "Well if she says that she has to have it, I need to see some proof, some statute that says she does."
Webb County medical examiner Corrine Stern has been silent on the issue. We've tried to contact her on several occasions including going to her office today.
If the County Judge and Commissioners are right, she now joins the ranks of a half dozen medical examiners including the one in Lubbock county doing their oaths of office in the past months.
Tomorrow we have more on that story and how this could affect literally hundreds of local cases including the upcoming high profile Katherine Cardenas case in court. District Attorney Chilo Alaniz has yet to comment on the situation.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Anonymous said on Thursday, Sep 8 at 11:54 PM

I call BS on Stern not knowing about the oath.. She used to work as a ME in El Paso, she HAD to take an oath there as well. If not El Paso has some backtracking to do.

73577283
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Thursday, Sep 8 at 11:55 PM

The El Paso County Commissioners accepted the resignation of Dr. Corinne Stern, the Medical Examiner, during its meeting on June 27th. A synopsis of the meeting states

73577298
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Friday, Sep 9 at 8:51 AM

Is it me, or has she had issues everywhere she works?

73588664
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Reader said on Friday, Sep 9 at 8:53 AM

If taking an oath was a requirement for her employement in Webb County, the responsibility lied with the County Attorney (Homero Ramirez) to have requested one prior to her employment. She is a highly qualified person who is professional and very knowledgeable in her field. Dr. Corinne Stern is a qualified person who works long hours and prides herself in doing a good job. We are all quick to judge but also one needs to look at the motivation of the current county attorney. There was no need to make this public all they had to do is have her take the oath especially since the county had not one. Maybe Anna Laura Cavazos is upset because Dr. Stern ruled a death as natural and it did not give Cavazos the opportunity to sue a local hospital. There could have been millions to profit from this lawsuit.

73588807
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Do things right, you get paid for it said on Friday, Sep 9 at 11:24 AM

How many times the people of Laredo has had the bad reputation because the corruption in our political institutions? the city, the county all have corrupt personnel, directors and elected officials. We are tired of you. and that means YOU. I am glad that people can point at the faults and unethical procedures. Laredo seems like a refuge for crooks, killers, and thieves, even or other people that commited wrong in other parts of the United States. we have the right to know. We do not want Martin's administration style anymore. tired of politicians defrauding the good will of the citizens of Laredo.

73597408
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

robasol said on Friday, Sep 9 at 3:46 PM

who gives a **** about an oath? the qualifications speak for themselves! REALLY??? Doesn't HELLRADO have better news to offer than an oath? WOW this place really blows

73610458
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

uhhhhh said on Saturday, Sep 10 at 9:59 AM

ok pro8 how come you dont follow up on 8 liners hell they get raided and reopen within 24 hours.writing is on the wall they get raided due to no pay. when was the last raid? you need to follow up on this just like you did on this story or is it that we may find surprize some would call it a hand out

73634717
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Zebra said on Saturday, Sep 10 at 4:56 PM

The person that made the recommendation to hire her from a list of finalist wasthe former webb county administrator Carlos Villareal, now the city manager for Laredo. If you read last months edition of Laredos Stern does not even have a Doctorate in medicine but a general doctorate in hemopathy (the over all wellness of a person) how to help you stay healthy. She was never qualified. In El Paso they ran her out of town. Blame it on Villareal.

73644468
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

X-Laredo Onda said on Monday, Sep 12 at 11:08 AM

The DEAD don't need a doctor or medicine!!! "I solemnly swear that I will declare the dead, dead. If it looks like a bullet hole, I’ll call it a bullet hole. If it looks like the decedent drowned or expired due to heat related consequences or natural causes, I shall call it as such. I promise that I will follow the simple rules of evidence when collecting such and not contaminate it. So help me so on and so forth, blah, blah, and blah!!!!!” Put this one to bed people. Let’s move on…. There is nothing to see here….

73697343
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

brighter than TV said on Monday, Sep 12 at 4:42 PM

The TX Constitution requires that elected officals and appointed officers take an oath. Where is it written that she is an appointed officer? Perhaps she is a political appointee, but that is not the same as an officer. The Code of Criminal Procedure requires that a city with a population over 1 million create a medical examiner's office and appoint an examiner. Laredo does not have over a million residents, therefore, it is at our discretion to create an office and hire/fire according to our own rules. Where (in writing...code, statute, etc.) does it say that all work is now null & void? KGNS shows viewers slanted stories and does not do their homework. An oath is merely a ceremonial act and does not negate the fact that she performed her duties as a County employee and as a licensed medical examiner.

73712046
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thank you brighter than TV said on Tuesday, Sep 13 at 9:22 AM

Your are correct!! I guess County Attorney will need to think of something else to cry wolf about Dr. C. Stern. She just does not like her and frankly would like to see her lose her job.

73739218
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

KGNS-TV and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. Comments are posted on site immediately and without station moderation. If you feel a comment is inappropriate you may flag it for review. For guidelines on flagging comments see our Terms & Conditions. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

The Buzz On 8